Friday, October 31, 2025 Order By Phone: 1-866-297-2462 Largest Selection of Little Cigars on the Internet! Site By Line
Cookie Checker
  1. Home
  2. Candy
  3. Candy By Flavor

  4. Peanut Butter Candy

    113 products were found.
    Sort by :
    Atkinson Chick O Stick 160ct Jar

    Atkinson Chick O Stick 160ct Jar
    $26.49
    Qty:  
    Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 160ct Tub

    Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 160ct Tub
    $16.69
    Qty:  
    Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 1lb

    Atkinson Chick O Stick Nugget 1lb
    $6.09
    Qty:  
    Atkinson Chick O Stick Wrapped 1lb

    Atkinson Chick O Stick Wrapped 1lb
    $7.69
    Qty:  
    Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets 1lb

    Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets 1lb
    $12.39
    Qty:  
    Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Bag

    Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Bag
    $4.49
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Black Cow Bite Size 160pc Tub

    Atkinsons Black Cow Bite Size 160pc Tub
    $14.29
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box

    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box
    $28.99
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box Plus Free 48ct

    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 24ct Box Plus Free 48ct
    $30.09
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 36ct Box

    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 36ct Box
    $12.89
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Box

    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Box
    $10.09
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.21oz 160pc Tub

    Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.21oz 160pc Tub
    $18.99
    Qty:  
    Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.34oz 160pc Tub

    Atkinsons Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars 0.34oz 160pc Tub
    $28.19
    Qty:  
    Butterfinger 36ct Box

    Butterfinger 36ct Box
    $47.09
    Qty:  
    Clark Giant Peanut Butter Cups 24ct Box

    Clark Giant Peanut Butter Cups 24ct Box
    $60.69
    Qty:  
    Dove Christmas Peanut Butter Reindeer 1.1oz

    Dove Christmas Peanut Butter Reindeer 1.1oz
    $2.69
    Qty:  
    Dove Christmas Peanut Butter Reindeer 2.2oz

    Dove Christmas Peanut Butter Reindeer 2.2oz
    $4.59
    Qty:  
    M and M Mega Peanut Butter 24ct Box

    M and M Mega Peanut Butter 24ct Box
    $56.39
    Qty:  
    M and M Peanut Butter 24ct Box

    M and M Peanut Butter 24ct Box
    $37.99
    Qty:  
    M and M Peanut Butter and Jelly 24ct Box

    M and M Peanut Butter and Jelly 24ct Box
    $34.99
    Qty:  
    Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 50ct Tub

    Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 50ct Tub
    $25.89
    Qty:  
    Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 8oz Tub

    Marshas Homemade Buckeyes 8oz Tub
    $9.79
    Qty:  
    Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 160ct Jar

    Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 160ct Jar
    $16.59
    Qty:  
    Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 3oz Bag

    Mary Jane Molasses and Peanut Butter 3oz Bag
    $2.69
    Qty:  
    Palmer Peanut Butter Hearts 1lb

    Palmer Peanut Butter Hearts 1lb
    $8.79
    Qty:  
    Reeses Big Cup With Reeses Puff King 16ct Box

    Reeses Big Cup With Reeses Puff King 16ct Box
    $35.39
    Qty:  
    Reeses Dipped Animal Crackers 4.25oz Bag

    Reeses Dipped Animal Crackers 4.25oz Bag
    $5.89
    Qty:  
    Reeses Fast Break 18ct Box

    Reeses Fast Break 18ct Box
    $31.89
    Qty:  
    Reeses Nutrageous Reg 18ct Box

    Reeses Nutrageous Reg 18ct Box
    $24.79
    Qty:  
    Reeses Peanut Butter Cups 36ct Box

    Reeses Peanut Butter Cups 36ct Box
    $39.49
    Qty:  
    Taffy Delight Peanut Butter Flavored Salt Water Taffy 16oz Jar

    Taffy Delight Peanut Butter Flavored Salt Water Taffy 16oz Jar
    $12.89
    Qty:  
    Taffy Town Peanut Butter Flavored Salt Water Taffy 1lb

    Taffy Town Peanut Butter Flavored Salt Water Taffy 1lb
    $6.59
    Qty:  
    Zagnut 18CT Box

    Zagnut 18CT Box
    $29.79
    Qty:  
    5th Avenue 18ct Box

    5th Avenue 18ct Box
    $31.89
    Expected On 10/31/2025
    Email me when instock
    Anthony Thomas Buckeyes 60ct Box

    Anthony Thomas Buckeyes 60ct Box
    $25.09
    Ashers Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Easter Pals 1lb

    Ashers Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Easter Pals 1lb
    $13.79
    Atkinson Chick O Stick Flat 1lb

    Atkinson Chick O Stick Flat 1lb
    $7.09
    Atkinson Honeycombed Peanut 1 lb

    Atkinson Honeycombed Peanut 1 lb
    $5.79
    Atkinson Honeycombed Peanuts 1lb

    Atkinson Honeycombed Peanuts 1lb
    $5.49
    Atkinson Peanut Butter Eyeballs 1lb

    Atkinson Peanut Butter Eyeballs 1lb
    $4.89
    Atkinson Peanut Butter Skeleton Bones 1lb

    Atkinson Peanut Butter Skeleton Bones 1lb
    $5.39
    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Bag

    Atkinsons Chick O Stick 48ct Bag
    $7.29
    Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 1 lb

    Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 1 lb
    $5.39
    Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 36ct

    Atkinsons Peanut Butter Bars 36ct
    $12.39
    Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Peanut Butter Cups King 24ct

    Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Peanut Butter Cups King 24ct
    $33.19
    Clark Peanut Butter Cups 24ct Box

    Clark Peanut Butter Cups 24ct Box
    $34.79
    Flipz Peanut Butter 5oz Pouch

    Flipz Peanut Butter 5oz Pouch
    $2.39
    Holiday Reeses Peanut Butter Cups Red Green Gold 1lb

    Holiday Reeses Peanut Butter Cups Red Green Gold 1lb
    $9.49
    M and M Peanut Butter and Jelly King Size 24ct Box

    M and M Peanut Butter and Jelly King Size 24ct Box
    $50.59
    Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs 1lb

    Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs 1lb
    $10.69
    Palmer Peanut Butter Filled Chocolate Kringles 1lb

    Palmer Peanut Butter Filled Chocolate Kringles 1lb
    $6.49
    Palmer White Chocolate Flavored Peanut Butter Hearts 1lb

    Palmer White Chocolate Flavored Peanut Butter Hearts 1lb
    $6.59
    Peanut Butter Kisses 1lb

    Peanut Butter Kisses 1lb
    $5.49
    Peanut Butter Pumpkin Cups 1lb

    Peanut Butter Pumpkin Cups 1lb
    $6.19
    Reeses Big Cup Potato Chip King 16ct Box

    Reeses Big Cup Potato Chip King 16ct Box
    $34.49
    Reeses Big Cup Potato Chip Reg 16ct Box

    Reeses Big Cup Potato Chip Reg 16ct Box
    $20.39
    Reeses Big Cup Pretzel King 16ct Box

    Reeses Big Cup Pretzel King 16ct Box
    $34.49
    Reeses Big Cup With Reeses Puff 1.2oz 16ct Box

    Reeses Big Cup With Reeses Puff 1.2oz 16ct Box
    $20.79
    Reeses Christmas Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Santas 9.1oz Bag

    Reeses Christmas Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Santas 9.1oz Bag
    $4.69
    Reeses Christmas Peanut Butter Bells 9oz Bag

    Reeses Christmas Peanut Butter Bells 9oz Bag
    $4.69
        
    Page    of   2